DO-260B ... well it is compliant

Ok there is compliant, and there is useful. DO-260B is certainly the former, and not likely the latter. ADS-B is full of challenges, and opportunities. Upgrading equipment is expensive. Some equipment is really close to usable, and some just flat out needs to be replaced. The mode S transponder certainly is one of those items.

If an aircraft has a mode S transponder on it, it can almost do ADS-B out. The payload on a stock mode S transponder can only be 56bits. For ADS-B out, the transponder needs to send 112 bits. The extended squitter (ES) is the change needed to make a mode S transponder ADS-B out compliant. DO-260B is the standard needed to "convert" mode S to mode  S with ES.

ADS-B out is needed by 2020, and if an aircraft has a mode S transponder, getting the transponder updated to DO-260B will  make the aircraft compliant. ADS-B out will make the aircraft as functional as it is today in a RADAR environment. There is no additional functionality available to the pilots on the aircraft. The big win for the pilots is ADS-B in. DO-260B has no provision for IN, only out.

Most 1090ES transponders are only transmitting the ADS-B message. To receive the ADS-B message, a separate receiver is needed. Usually jets will will have the TCAS system as a transponder receiver. This unit has the ability to receive all 1090MHz transponder messages. Using the TCAS receiver may allow an aircraft to have ADS-B in, if it has the proper facilities to send the message to a display, or computer for displaying.

Yes, 2020 seemed a long time away when the FAA said we all need ADS-B out. DO-260B might seem a tempting quick answer for older aircraft. It could be cheap, but likely it will cost a bunch to get a WAAS enabled GPS feeding the mode S transponder with ES. UAT's won't cut it for jets, so the right answer will probably be a new transponder that will do a proper job of handling ADS-B messages, along with a modern WAAS GPS receiver.

I am open to arguments, but overall it is going to cost a lot of money to equip for ADS-B in any aircraft.

UAT or 1090ES?

If you are considering ADS/B, there is a choice to make. Do you install a Universal Access Transceiver (UAT) or the Mode S transponder that has an extended squitter (1090-ES)? It all depends...

What country are you in? If you aren't in the USA, then the choice is pretty much made. The USA offers the option of a UAT. The rest of the world needs Mode S transponders for ADS/B installations.

If you are in the USA, and you mostly fly above FL180, then the choice is pretty much made again. The FAA doesn't allow aircraft flying above 18,000ft to use the UAT. It just makes sense to get the 1090-ES transponder that will do Mode S if you want take advantage of ADS/B and fly about FL180.

The UAT transmits and receives on 978MHz, the 1090-ES transmits and receives on 1090MHz. The ADS/B system will allow all participating aircraft to see each other. If the two devices work on different frequencies, how does a 1090MHz transceiver see a 978MHz transceiver? The ground stations will repeat the 978MHz messages on 1090MHz, as well as repeat the 1090MHz message on 978MHz. The ground station will also show both messages on the "RADAR" scope, so the air traffic controller knows where everyone is.

The FAA separated the two systems for a couple reasons. The 978MHz devices can handle more data (has more bandwidth), so more aircraft in a concentrated area will work without overloading ground stations or other aircraft. The 1090 Mode S transponders are already on the larger faster aircraft that are flying higher, so the expense should be minimized (I am repeating the FAA here, in reality, most operators will need to replace the transponders they have to get the extended squitter feature).

The UAT's are even more useful, since the FAA will broadcast extra information. The two extra messages that the FAA is broadcasting are the TIS/B and FIS/B. The 1090-ES system will get TIS/B, but not FIS/B.

TIS/B is Traffic Information Service-Broadcast, where non-ADS/B equipped aircraft will show up on the aircraft display, similar to ADS/B equipped aircraft. The ground station will broadcast the position of aircraft that are only visible on RADAR. As a pilot, you will be able to see more of what the controller sees.

FIS/B is Flight Information Service-Broadcast. Flight information includes weather, and aeronautical products. While XM provides some weather, that you must subscribe to, the FIS/B is free to everyone. The XM product may have additional information, or be more timely. The FIS/B data is what the FAA will be looking at, including potentially air traffic control. The aeronautical products appear to be weather like items, such as NOTAMs and SUA status.

Exactly what device to get will depend on the capability of the chosen display. Many of the MFD manufacturers will take either device for input, the displayed information may help make the choice. Some will show the weather RADAR information in great detail, others will show it blocky or not at all. Over the next couple years, the MFDs are sure to get better.

Should you wait, or should you buy today? Today the ADS/B MFD technology is being developed. Over the next 5 years, the technology will surely mature. Having ADS/B in on a tablet computer will allow a pilot to get their feet wet, sooner. By 2020, most aircraft will be required to have ADS/B out, which probably means, unless someone builds an under $1000 solution to ADS/B out only, most aircraft will be equipped with ADS/B in and out.

Can you get rid of your transponder once you have ADS/B? No, the Mode/C component will still be needed for RADAR service and TCAS for non-ADS/B equipped aircraft.

It'll be an interesting couple years going forward. What do you think?

Transponders

Surveillance RADAR is very useful, and can be augmented like GPS. RADAR alone can only tell range and azimuth. If the transponder is added, the range and azimuth can be augmented with altitude and identification.

Transponders are transceivers, like DME. When the RADAR interrogation is received, the transponder transmits a specific response. For most GA aircraft, the response will be the identification (mode A), and the altitude (Mode C). The transponder concept comes from a technology developed around WWII, used for positively identifying friend or foe targets (IFF). Early targeting RADAR on aircraft could identify targets, but not who they were. Occasionally people will still call a transponder  an IFF box.

If the transponder is Mode S, the response will include quite a bit more information. The mode  S transponder has a payload capable of holding identification, altitude, and various other information, depending on mode. The message can be 56 or 112 (extended squitter or ES) bytes and include a 24 digit ICAO identifier assigned to each unique aircraft. Location and speed can also be encoded in the response. There are various modes the Mode S transponder will work in. (For a good article that covers much of the ModeS modes, see this EETimes article)

Usually aircraft transponders will transmit on 1090MHz. TCAS receivers and RADAR antennas will all be expecting to receive messages on 1090MHz. The transponder is mostly listening, but can be quite busy in class B airspace, with several TCAS units pinging traffic in the area. 

The code that is entered in the transponder is asigned by ATC. There are only 4096 unique codes, and some are reserved (IE 1200, 0000, etc). The numbers are limited to 0-7 or octal digits (octal = 8, and 0-7 are 8 distinct values). Octal is a throwback to early computers that were used for Air Traffic Control, and numbers were represented in octal values. On a busy day, there may be more than 4000 aircraft in the air at once, how does air traffic control keep conflicts out? Certain ranges of transponder (squawk) codes are reserved for local traffic (staying in the area, like training, or ferry flights). Other ranges are for long distance flying, some east, some west, depending on origin and destination. Occasionally, something unexpected happens, and two aircraft with the same transponder code appear in the same area, and the RADAR display will alert the controller to that.

The altitude that all the transponders send is pressure altitude. Pilots will set the altimeter on the ground to local barometric pressure. The altitude encoder attached to the transponder is not adjusted to local barometer. ATC will set their scope to the local pressure. Having ATC consistently reading the same uncompensated pressure will allow more consistent readings aircraft to aircraft. Sometimes pilots will forget to change their altimeter, or set it wrong, and this would cause trouble for ATC trying to figure out what everyone's altitude is. If ATC is saying the aircraft reporting altitude is significantly different than the pilot thinks they are flying, ATC may ask the pilot to stop reporting altitude, and the pilot will switch to Mode A.

Most Mode S transponders are capable or working in Mode A/C or just Mode A as well. Mode S transponders, with their large payloads can be used for ADS/B as well. ADS/B will require other  transponders in the area to be sending specific payloads, in order to plot the position on the receiving aircraft's display.

Transponders add a great deal to RADAR. Transponders will stay on aircraft even after the aircraft are switched to ADS/B. Eventually, the need for a transponder will be replaced by the ADS/B system, but that may be many years. 

ASDI what is it?

When we go to FlightAware.com, FlightExplorer or any of the other flight tracking web sites or apps, they have a lot of good information. The information all comes from the FAA, for free! Ever think about the FAA and how they collect that information? How does is all come together? 

All over the country, there are RADAR sensors. These RADAR sensors are scanning the skies 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. The output of the RADAR sensor is sent to a computer, where the range and azimuth data is correlated to the transponder and altitude data. In the drawing below, the black line coming out of the RADAR dish is the interrogation signal, the black line coming back it the "skin paint" reflection signal, and the blue line is the transponder broadcast from the aircraft.

The computers correlate the transponder code to the flight plan, and take the RADAR returns and calculate a speed, altitude and track that the aircraft would be on. The flight plan helps determine where the airplane will be, based on the speed and time since last sample. 

All of the track information for all of the RADAR systems are sent to the FAA command center where they are made available for display in the various FAA systems that need the information (IE URET, TRACONs, ERAM, TFMA, etc).

One of those system that get the FAA RADAR data is the Aircraft Situation Display to Industry (ASDI). The ASDI data is availble to the airlines and other organizations in the aviation industry. The information includes flight plans, position reports, departure, and cancel flight plans. Using this information sites like FlightAware can present aircraft on maps for the general public. 

The ASDI data only contains non-blocked RADAR and flight plan data for aircraft with IFR flight plans in the US and some of Europe. There is an option available to private aircraft allowing them to block the ASDI data for competitive reasons (IE the president of ATT doesn't want the Verizon corporation to know about some special meetings with a partner or something).  

There are about 4 different kind of feeds of ASDI data. There is the internal FAA feed, the need to know real-time feed, the need to know real-time with European data, and a delayed feed. The real-time feeds are for the airlines and such to use for business reasons. The delayed feed is for the web sites visited by the general public. The delay is like 5 minutes, so it is good enough for people to know when to show up at the airport to get their loved one. 

There is a bit of information that can be derived from the ASDI data. Looking at the ASDI data, someone can determine which airports are taking delays with many aircraft holding. Other things can include looking at the projected track, and weather data to see when it might be best to re-route an aircraft because it is heading toward some convective activity. Airport operators can use the data to count operations relative to other airports, to help improve service. 

The ASDI data feed contains a lot of data. The position reports will be updates of aircraft positions every time the computers are aware of a position update (IE every 12 seconds for enroute RADAR, 5 seconds for TRACON, or 1 second for ADS-B). Typically Monday through Friday in the US there will be 3000-5000 aircraft in the air from 6am to 6pm. 

The FAA has many other services similar to ASDI. Most of it isn't as useful. ASDI is a great resource. 

What do you think.

ADS/B and RNP

There are many uses for the GPS data in and out of the aircraft. The GPS location is very accurate, normally. Knowing where the aircraft thinks it is can help ATC in many instances.

Shortcomings of RADAR

RADAR will send out a radio signal in a cone shape. The farther the aircraft is from the antenna, the larger the target will appear on the radar screen. The location displayed to the air traffic controller isn't as accurate when the aircraft is far from the antenna. The RADAR cannot "see" straight up either, so if the aircraft flies directly over the antenna, the software has to guess where the aircraft will be.

RADAR can only get range and azimuth information. The RADAR cannot determine altitude. Altitude information is sent from the aircraft in  the transponder message. When the aircraft transponder hears the RADAR interrogation, the transponder responds with the transponder code and altitude (with mode-s, there may be more information).

Most short range RADAR has about a 5 second sweep. The long range radars have a 12 second sweep. The sweep time is how long the RADAR antenna takes to turn once. The sweep time is how long it takes between aircraft updates. If the aircraft is going 600knots, and the sweep is 12 seconds, the aircraft moves about 2 miles between sweeps. 

The RADAR software has to do some correlations between the raw RADAR range and  azimuth information, and the transponder code altitude message. Usually, there is only one aircraft that comes into RADAR range at a time at the same point, so it is easy to correlate this, but occasionally two targets may appear at different altitudes at the same place. The software will occasionally get this wrong.

Why ADS/B is Better

ABS/B out messages from the aircraft will usually be the same quality. The GPS accuracy will be pretty consistent in an area, and be very accurate. The target drawn on the air traffic controllers screen will be the same size as the target moves across the screen.

The ADS/B message will contain both location and altitude information in a single message. The software will not need to correlate that data. During times when the ADS/B aircraft are operating in the RADAR environment, correlation will still be done with the raw RADAR and the transponder messages. The ADS/B information will only make correlation more accurate.

The ADS/B location is broadcast about once a second. The controllers screen will update every time it hears the ADS/B signal.

ADS/B will broadcast to the aircraft in the area without relying on ground station. The FAA having two frequencies, 978MHz and1090ES almost requires a ground station for ADS/B to work. There are other benefits to the ground stations, in that they will broadcast weather (FIS/B) and traffic (TIS/B) from non-participating aircraft.

RNP and ANP

In most of this and previous articles I have hesitated on specifying the accuracy of GPS location information. GPS accuracy changes during the day, and in certain locations. The current accuracy is defined as Actual Navigation Performance (ANP) and is measured in miles. Sometimes the ANP will be down to feet in all directions, sometimes it will be in miles.

To fly a GPS approach it is necessary to have an ANP of 0.3 miles or better. 0.3 miles means the receiver is able to pinpoint it's position to less than 1500 feet. The 0.3 mile value is called the Required Navigation Performance (RNP). To fly with any more precision, special training is needed. The FAA has many public RNP approaches with levels as low as 0.1 miles, or about 500ft.

This sounds pretty sloppy, 500ft is bigger than 10 houses.  Remember, the GPS receiver is calculating where it was when it heard the last update from the satellite, but the aircraft is carrying that receiver at 150-200kts on final.  The receiver is throwing values into the Kalman filter as fast as it can, and guessing that the pilot won't turn more that 3 degrees per second, assuming a mostly straight course.  It ain't easy, 500ft is pretty good.

Many commercial aircraft display the ANP and RNP values at the bottom of the navigation display. The display on a 737 is the instrument on the left (see slightly above this link).

NextGen future

There is a lot to NextGen technologies. Alaska has been playing with ADS/B since the late 1990's. The FAA is financing more Capstone work in Alaska even in the time of sequestering. Much of the enroute NextGen requires ERAM, but that is still in process, and is partially on hold until the FAA gets their financial situation in order.

The FAA is currently wanting to require all aircraft to participate in ADS/B out by 2020. There will be some challenges to that. With the current financial situation and things being on hold, will the FAA be ready for all aircraft to be using ADS/B? What about the Luscome 8F that never had an alternator, what will it use to power the GPS and transmitter needed? What will the FAA use to track aircraft with electrical failure?

Some airlines are equipping their aircraft with RNP and ADS/B. Some have had a challenge reaping the benefits from the upgrades. The other airlines are waiting until some indication they will reap some benefits. The FAA and the airlines are still trying to figure out the best time to move forward.